Do principles like fairness and kindness matter in New Zealand?
Illustration: Getty ImagesRelatedArticlesModule - editorials
Fair and square
Amid a hate speech and free speech furore, there are people working to build a better New Zealand.Club sandwiches, two days in a row. Iâm really a wholegrain bread person, but thereâs something irresistible about club sandwiches: those soft, crust-less savoury layers. Theyâre a bit old-fashioned â" in a good way â" reminiscent of church hall gatherings and community observances.
And so it was they appeared, twice, on a sunny-showery Auckland weekend at the end of July. The Saturday afternoon event I attended was a memorial for a colleagueâs mother: ââ¦a gathering to share laughter and memories of a la rge life well livedâ. It was held in a secular space, small and pretty, that even without religious symbols still managed to feel spiritual â" certainly celebratory of the human spirit, among the stories, poetry, laughter and tears for Shirley.
Gimme shelter: Why can't Kiwis rent their homes securely and comfortably?by Virginia Larson Social issues
White noise: When white privilege drowns out realityby Virginia Larson Social issues
New agenders: The prickly iss ue of transgender politicsby Virginia Larson
On Sunday, I joined friends and supporters of Graeme MacCormick â" and what seemed the entire congregation from St Andrewâs Church â" at the adjacent hall to launch the former judgeâs memoir, Recollections and Reflections.
Graeme wrote an essay for North & South in 2011 and weâve stayed in touch. In his opinion piece, The Damage Done, he made a case for the universal monitoring of every baby born in New Zealand, and intervening when necessary. It was written out of compassion, but also from the coal-face perspective of 16 years on the bench of the Family Court, observing a relentless toll of child abuse and neglect. Then and now, he continues to champion the work of the Brainwave Trust, which has done much to raise awareness of research into brain devel opment, especially the crucial first three years of a childâs life when the brain is still wiring up, laying the foundations for adult life.
After the sandwiches and clinking of church hall teacups, there was a warm, heartfelt introduction from Judy Bailey â" yes, the Judy Bailey, whoâs on the Brainwave Trust board. Graeme followed with his âsupplementary commentsâ, beginning with an explanation of why his faith occupies the front section of his book, with personal memoir at the end.
For non-religious me, Graeme represents Christian faith at its best. My dips into his book confirm him to be a man of humility, kindness and open-mindedness; his decisions both as a judge and human rights commissioner would have been firm when they needed to be, and always fair and thoughtful. For all the sad, sorry, venal cases that have passed before him, heâs never lost his belief that we can change the trajectory of all our childrenâs lives â" and build a better New Zealand. His comment at the book launch, âThose with an abused or neglected start, who end up aggrieved and with nothing to lose, will always pose a danger, and a cost, to societyâ is echoed in Paul Littleâs piece in this month's issue. In The Case for Closing Prisons, the connection between early harm and our shameful incarceration rates is made by a number of expert interviewees.
I ask Graeme if heâs attending Andrew Littleâs justice summit in August. Heâs not, but says heâs a supporter of Little and his handling of the justice portfolio. âWhile he was leader of the Opposition, I wrote to him a couple of times and his replies gave the clear impression he was responding personally, not having had the letters written for him â" as has appeared to be the case with almost every other political response Iâve ever received.â
I pester Graeme further by email, as our print deadline coincides with the visit of Canadian far-right activists Lauren Southern and Stefan Molyneux, recently banned by Mayor Phil Goff from speaking at Auckland Council venues, and the subject of much-heated debate over free speech and hate speech. It seems the sort of issue that might well end up in front of a human rights commissioner. Graeme replies that heâs not studied the pairâs views sufficiently to be definitive in his comments, but adds: âIf the mayor thinks their views do not sit comfortably with the culture of tolerance and inclusiveness that Auckland is trying to promote, then I have no problem with saying theyâre not welcome to use council-owned venues. The downside is the publicity it gives them.
âPeopleâs human rights frequently compete, and it becomes necessary to strike a balance. Generally, I favour people being able to say pretty much what they want, with the rubbish just being ignored â" or rather what I regard as rubbish. A response usually only indicates that you regard the comments worthy of response. But actually, incit ing racial or religious hatred is another matter. Where you draw the line is always difficult...â
Had he been tasked, you know Graeme MacCormick would have drawn that line â" straight, fair and principled.
â¢ Graemeâs memoir is for sale only via a contribution to the Brainwave Trust (suggested donation $30 plus $5 postage). Email email@example.com.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
This article first appeared in the September 2018 issue of North & South.
Follow North & South on on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram and sign up to the weekly e-mail
Most Read93000 2018-07-15 00:00:00Z
The cult that's infiltrated NZ schools, campuses and churchesby Rosel Labone 94745 2018-08-10 00:00:00Z Television
For once, the media left Lauren Southern and Stefan Molyneux rattledby Diana Wichtel 94553 2018-08-06 07:52:16Z Politics
Simon Bridges' surprising stance on cannabis and euthanasiaby Graham Adams 94810 2018-08-10 13:01:12Z Environment
Banning plastic bags in NZ just the tip of the icebergby Ellie Hooper 94741 2018-08-09 09:11:48Z
Why are we afraid of free speech and protest? NZ has a proud tradition of itby The Listener AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage
Featured94891 8/13/2018 12:11:41 PM
Don Brash nominated for New Zealander of the Yearby RNZ 94869 8/13/2018 10:16:57 AM Education
How free should speech on campus be?by Ana Mari Cauce, Clayton Rose, Connie Ledoux Book 94845 8/13/2018 7:05:14 AM Health
Dialysis for NZ patients 'rationed' as ineligible immigrants treatedby Gill Bonnett 94842 8/13/2018 6:48:50 AM Business
Fare strike suggested as Wellington commuters vent about new bus networkby Emma Hatton
Latest94581 2018-08-13 00:00:00Z
Do principles like fairness and kindness matter inâ¦by Virginia Larson
Amid a hate speech and free speech furore, there are people working to build a better New Zealand.Read more 94680 2018-08-13 00:00:00Z Education
How King's College nurtured this student's excitinâ¦by North & South
Alumna and Fulbright Graduate Award winner Isabelle Smith explains how the school gave her the opportunity to explore.Read more 94751 2018-08-13 00:00:00Z Movies
It's LBJ â" minus all contradiction and complexityby James Robins
The nuance of LBJâs presidency goes missing in Rob Reinerâs tepid biopic.Read more 94871 2018-08-13 00:00:00Z Books
The sparkling 50-year career of Dunedin master jewâ¦by Linda Herrick
âI hit bits of metal with a hammer,â is Tony Williamsâ modest summary of his career as a master craftsman whose pieces are in demand worldwide.Read more 94389 2018-08-12 00:00:00Z Politics
The house that Norm built: The influence of Normanâ¦by John Summers
Norman Kirkâs squat, cinder-block home still stands in Kaiapoi, a testament to backbreaking DIY and a key theme of his political career â" housing.Read more 94701 2018-08-12 00:00:00Z Profiles
How a fatherless Kiwi teen rose to be a millionairâ¦by Joanne Black
Sky TV entrepreneur Craig Heatley believes itâs easier than ever for Kiwi business creators â" as long as they can overcome NZâs inferiority complex.Read more 94823 2018-08-12 00:00:00Z Television
Next of Kin examines the impact of terrorism on viâ¦by Catherine Woulfe
In contrast to most television shows, the new British drama focuses on the fallout of terrorism, rather than the action.Read more 94713 2018-08-12 00:00:00Z Business
Craig Heatley's schoolboy foray in the property maâ¦by Joan ne Black
Three years after his father died, Craig Heatley made his first foray into property, laying down $200 on a $10,000 lot. He was still in school.Read moreSource: Google News New Zealand | Netizen 24 New Zealand